BE IT ENACTED BY THE YOUTH LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA YOUTH LEGISLATURE –
Limit the Use of Solitary Confinement
The purpose of this bill is to limit the amount of time a prisoner can be held in solitary confinement to 30 days when
not dealing with murder or severe assault. This is necessary to lessen abuse in the prison system and aid in
rehabilitation of convicted criminals.
SECTION II - JUSTIFICATION
Minnesota currently uses a tiered system for assigning solitary confinement length, which allows up to 90 days for
assault without major injury, and up to 60 days just for possession of contraband. Solitary confinement is known to
cause severe mental harm. Deprivation of human contact causes prisoners to feel anxiety, depression, paranoia, and even
aggression. This system moves prisoners backwards in the reform and rehabilitation process which it is supposed to help
The Mandela Rules (also known as the Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners), adopted by the United
Nations, state that solitary confinement should never be used other than as a last resort, and never for more than 15
days. Furthermore, solitary confinement costs the government much more than normal confinement, and limiting the use of
it will save money. The prolonged use of solitary confinement when not absolutely necessary (in cases of murder or
assault) contradicts the goals of the prison system and causes more harm than good.
SECTION III - DEFINITIONS
“Prisoner” will be defined as any incarcerated person under the care of the Minnesota prison system
“Solitary confinement” will be defined as the isolation of a prisoner in a cell separated from others with extremely
limited human interaction for 22-24 hours of the day.
“Severe assault” will be defined as any assault which causes great bodily harm, ex. Physical disfigurement, extended
loss of consciousness, and assault with a dangerous weapon.
This bill calls for no specific funding, as prisoners now not in solitary for more than 30 days will return to their
normal housing, which has funding directed towards it already. Solitary confinement is actually more expensive than
normal confinement, as it requires much more staffing.
SECTION V – PENALTIES/ENFORCEMENT
Reports of the misuse of solitary confinement would be investigated by the Department of Corrections’ Office of Special
Investigations (OSI), and continued offenses could result in the shutdown of the violating facility.
SECTION VI – EFFECTIVE DATE